Skip to content

Menu

Creative Testing Your best ad is wearing out. Every new one loses to it.

Fair tests, then keep the winners.We give clearly different ideas a fair test on Meta and TikTok, then keep the winners running.

This form needs JavaScript.

Reach us another way:

WhatsApphello@supertoasty.com

Tell us about your ads

Our team will review your details and contact you about the next steps.

  • A new reason to buy in every test
  • Fatigue spotted before results slide
  • Tested with Meta’s and TikTok’s own tools

Business process analyst

Why new ads lose

Ten new ads. Still one idea.

Meta picks which of your ads each person sees.

Near-copies chase the same people, so one takes the budget.

  • A new person.

    A customer, your nurse or the owner does the talking.

  • A new opening.

    The first three seconds ask a different question.

  • A new reason to buy.

    Speed, price, proof or a worry: each its own ad.

Source: Meta for Business, 27 Mar 2025, checked 18 Nov 2026.

One test round

Most ads lose. One earns the budget.

An honest round shows the losers, and why they lost.

  • Retired.

    Eight colours of one photo: one idea, one result.

  • No clear difference.

    An answer too: that change doesn’t matter, so stop testing it.

  • Kept.

    The winner keeps the budget. The next round builds on it.

  • You pick the ideas.

    Only you know which promises your business can keep.

Curious which of your ads would win? Tell us.

Get Started

Judged on customers

Most taps. Fewest bookings.

The ad people tap most often brings the curious, who never book. We judge the winner on enquiries and bookings, not taps.

  • Bookings and sales.

    Pulled from your apps into one place.

  • A real customer, in your words.

    You tell us which enquiries count before the test starts.

A fair test

Every ad gets the same start.

Meta’s A/B test and TikTok’s Split Test give each version its own share.

Launch new ads side by side and Meta soon favours one.

Testing on a small budget

Girard Media, an agency, says a test comparing conversion rates needs 1,000 to 3,000 conversions per version to be sure of the result (November 2025). Few small businesses get that many, so we judge on bigger, clearer differences.

Meta and TikTok help pages, checked 18 Nov 2026.

Before it wears out

Ads wear out. We watch the signs.

Creative fatigue: the same people have seen your ad too often, so each enquiry costs more.

  • Cost per result.

    What each enquiry costs. It creeps up before anything looks wrong.

  • Frequency.

    How often the same person has seen the ad.

  • Click rate.

    The share of people who tap. It falls as they tire of it.

Working with us

Each new ad reaches the right person.

A business process analyst makes sure each new ad reaches the right person with everything attached.

Business process analyst

Routes approvals to the right person.

After you press Submit

  1. 1We review your details.
  2. 2We talk it through with you.
  3. 3We propose a solution.
  • What we need first: access to your ad accounts and the app where your enquiries land.
  • The systems, the code and the accounts are yours.
  • From you: one person to approve each ad, and a list of claims your industry can’t make.
  • Priority access to Luna. Partners go to the front of the queue with our AI assistant.
  • We accept only a limited number of partnerships each quarter.

Questions

Why does Meta back just one ad?

Before your first test: how many ads, how long, what it costs.

What is ad creative testing?

Ad creative testing is a planned way of finding which ads bring customers. SuperToasty starts from ideas the client approves, runs clearly different ads against each other in the client’s own Meta or TikTok account, judges winners on enquiries and bookings, retires tired ads and keeps a record of every test. Every test uses live ads shown to real buyers.

  • Ideas you approve first
  • A fair test on each platform’s tools
  • A record of every test

A question we missed? Ask it in the form’s last box.

Get Started
How many ads should one test have?

A round holds a few clearly different ideas. Each test puts two of them side by side: TikTok’s Split Test compares “two different versions” (TikTok Ads help, checked 18 Nov 2026). The count matters less than the difference: five colour swaps of one ad are still one idea.

Is creative testing right for us?

Creative testing suits a business already running Meta or TikTok ads whose best ad is fading, whose new ads never beat the old one, or whose budget goes to one ad while the rest sit unspent. It is the wrong first step for a business with no ads running yet, or whose leads never reach a CRM: counting comes first.

Why does Meta spend it all on one ad?

Meta’s ranking system backs the ad it expects to win with each person, so a new ad gets little spend until it proves itself. Near-copies of that ad have nothing new to win with. We give each new idea a fair test first, on Meta’s own testing tools or with money set aside for it, and the winner keeps the budget.

How long should a test run?

A creative test runs at least as long as the platform advises. Meta recommends keeping A/B tests running “for at least two weeks or up to 30 days”; TikTok recommends Split Tests run “a minimum of 7 days” (both checked 18 Nov 2026). We make no edits while it runs. When the result is close, we say so and agree the call with you.

How often should we refresh our ads?

Ad refreshes follow the numbers. Cost per result creeping up, the same people seeing the ad more often and a falling click rate are the usual signs. TikTok’s own advice is to refresh “when delivery results exhibit a consistently declining trend” (TikTok Ads help, checked 18 Nov 2026). We check those numbers in your regular report, and an alert goes out when one needs attention.

Does Meta charge for its A/B test?

Meta’s A/B test and TikTok’s Split Test are built into each platform’s Ads Manager. Neither help page names a fee for the tool (both checked 18 Nov 2026); you pay for the ads the test shows, at the budget you set. Paid testing software exists too, but a small account rarely needs it. For our part, you get a clear scope and price before you commit.

How is this different from Meta Ads?

Creative Testing and Meta Ads split the work. Meta Ads covers the account: Meta’s Pixel and Conversions API (the code that tells Meta who bought), lead forms, and telling Meta which leads became buyers. Creative Testing covers what goes into the ads, on Meta or TikTok: which ideas get tested, how each gets a fair test, how a winner is called, and when an ad retires.

Do you test in our account, or with surveys?

Creative tests run in your own Meta or TikTok ad account, with live ads in front of real buyers. Survey panels play no part. The systems, the code and the accounts are yours.

A question we missed? Ask it in the form’s last box.

Get Started

Keep going

Not quite what you need?

See the rest of this group, or the service closest to this one.